
In an epic, highly anticipated rematch that had more storylines than a 2-hour Jerry Springer special, the outcome was determined appropriately by just a few dramatic, breathtaking moments.
The Giants and Patriots were locked in a relative stalemate until the final stages of the fourth quarter, when it appeared the Patriots were about to take the upper hand. However, after a few ill-fated Tom Brady passes and an expertly thrown Eli Manning rail shot, the tables were turned.
The box score won’t lead you to the victor; no, all you’ll see is that, for the most part, the two teams played similar football in almost every respect. At the end of the day, it just came down to big plays in critical situations: The Giants made them, and the Patriots didn’t. Simple as that.
Key Moments
- Chase Blackburn redeems himself after getting juked and burned by Aaron Hernandez for a 12-yd TD pass in the 3rd quarter by going up and pulling down a long Tom Brady pass intended for a less-than-100% Rob Gronkowski.
- The very open and typically sure-handed Wes Welker drops a 2nd-down pass in the 4th quarter that could have potentially sealed the deal for the Patriots.
- The Manning-Manningham connection, a play that was nearly as unbelievable as (and eerily similar to) David Tyree’s helmet grab in the 2007 Super Bowl, sparks an impressive go-ahead drive for the Giants.
- On the game’s final drive, Aaron Hernandez fails to pull in a spot-on pass from Tom Brady. On the same drive, Deion Branch can’t snag a relatively catchable ball thrown in his direction.
The game never comes down to one play. But it can come down to a few. And as much as I love to hate him, there’s not much more Tom Brady could have done. He was resilient against a relentless Giants’ pass rush, he scrambled around to extend plays, and he went to the right place with the ball. Even on the Blackburn interception, the match-up was favorable, and the specimen known as Gronk most likely catches that ball (or at least knocks it down) 9 times out of 10. A heated Giselle cut to the heart of the matter, albeit somewhat comically due to her foreign accent: Manning’s receivers stepped up, and Brady’s didn’t.
Too Much Significance?
The hallmark of the Patriots has long been their ability to execute with robotic precision and consistency. That seemed to be missing Sunday night with the uncharacteristic penalties, mental lapses, and dropped balls. It may have been that some Patriots just attached too much emotional significance to the game. Between just wanting to win, wanting to make up for missing the playoffs in 2008 and exiting the playoffs early in 2009 and 2010, and not wanting to come up short against the Giants for a second time, the cumulative pressure may have gotten to a few players. Ironically, it was Eli Manning and the Giants who exhibited the Patriots-esque cool confidence and detachment.
Did Gronk Help or Hurt the Patriots?
In the two weeks preceding the Super Bowl, the Patriots handled Gronk’s injury just as you would have expected them to: they were very careful not to say too much one way or the other so the Giants would have to continue to account for him in their practices and preparations. And once the game started, it was clear that the massive tight end was out there primarily to serve as a decoy. He wasn’t running or cutting at full speed, and after a season for the record books, he caught only 2 passes for 26 yards on 3 targets. The strategy seems to have worked, as New England remained in the game against a stellar defense until the clock expired and would have won if the other receivers had made the crucial catches already discussed. It would be unfair to just isolate the jump ball with Blackburn (or even the last pass of the game) and use that to support the argument that his injury significantly hindered the Patriots.
Playmakers
The larger problem the Patriots will need to address this off-season is the absence of a big-time playmaker on offense…and defense for that matter. Welker, Hernandez, and Gronkowski are all extremely talented and reliable, but they need to round out their passing attack with a big-bodied burner that can consistently stretch the defense and come up with grabs on down-field bombs. Their defense was statistically abysmal this season, but they have a core to build around with Wilfork and Mayo. And analysts seem to think they have some promising young players in their secondary that can mature and develop.
What’s Next for the Giants?
The Giants had the elements of a championship squad but needed to address some shortcomings in performance, namely turnovers and play in the second half of both games and the season. Having resolved those issues, the Giants will just need to maintain and repeat going forward. Coughlin will need to continue to bring in players who will both buy into his system and positively contribute. The defense needs to play with intensity all season long. And Eli will need to continue to combine big plays with ball security and good decision-making.